ChatGPT Outperforms Google's Bard in Answering Gastroenterology Queries
ChatGPT 4.0 demonstrates higher reliability and accuracy compared to Google Bard in providing responses to gastroenterology-related queries, indicating its greater potential for enhancing healthcare delivery.
Summary
- The article aims to evaluate the reliability and accuracy of ChatGPT 4.0 and Google Bard AI tools in answering gastroenterology questions.
- Typical gastroenterology queries were input into both tools and responses evaluated by independent reviewers using a Likert scale.
- Responses were cross-referenced with authoritative gastroenterology guidelines to determine accuracy.
- Statistical analysis conducted includes descriptive statistics and Mann-Whitney U hypothesis testing.
- ChatGPT 4.0 shows higher average reliability rating of 6.23 versus 2.04 for Google Bard. Reliability rating difference is statistically significant.
- For accuracy, ChatGPT 4.0 also leads with average rating of 4.48 versus 2.48 for Google Bard. Accuracy rating difference is statistically significant.
- Limitations include narrow question set and inability to do detailed correlation analysis.
- Concludes ChatGPT 4.0 outperforms Google Bard in gastroenterology domains, underscoring the potential of AI tools to enhance healthcare.
- Highlights need for broader, more diverse assessments of AI capabilities in healthcare going forward.